Phenomenon

Having an arrow does not automatically give a sniper any sort of edge. Your damage will be next to nothing without a decent weapon. A creator only needs acid demonstration and high intelligence to do high damage on enemies, and begin to break equipment. Limitless Acid Demonstration is out of the question in my opinion, not only does this skill break armors and weapons, but stun locks enemies and forces the enemy to default neutral reducing equipment. Acid Demonstration should run out in non-command situations, just like healing items would. Otherwise, @storage is easily useable. I can't believe ANYONE here really believes people don't use creators because of the price or constant need of bottles. Arrows are easily makeable in official servers, while bottle grenades and acid bottles are not. Acid Demonstration is a luxury and dangerous in PvP type sitatuions, as the creator is 100% likely to outlast anyone's FCP as long as they live and their enemy is not another creator. Creators are in the class of professors/high wizards, highly dangerous but easily countered. In order to create balance I believe an HP boost in Tao and an increase in mammomite damage is in order, not giving them limitless access to a dangerous skill, and certainly not an unncessary price drop in supplies, it's EASY to make zeny. Edit : I mean for god's sake, even if they were to have limitless acid demonstration, a creator without thanatos (which is many) are instantly nullified with a simply equipment change and their offensive skills aren't very powerful, if you want to make creators more widely used, diversify their offensive skills, not create limitless access to a dangerous skill.

I can hunt 1m zeny in under 2 minutes, so I disagree with the statement that the price is detering people from using the class. People just want the easy road out, instead of actually taking the time to be productive and work towards a goal.

Well, I feel the donaters would feel cheated if some sort of reduction wasn't kept, that's IMO though.

I'm not sure, but I don't think you require both the sun and moon aurora to have the stat bonus covered for the entire day, I believe they are not only differ in appearance from their event reward counterpart, but differ as well in that they give the stat bonus at all times, so lowering their cost below 60~80 each seems unmerited.

I disagree, their is a huge influx of zeny already as it is, and making zeny from 0 is REALLY easy, if you take the time to actually work for it. Acid Demonstration does HUGE damage on non-ghost type MvPs, and would facilitate MvPing and creator survival, as a near limitless supply of Acid Demonstration would be present in their storage. It's not necessarily a bad idea to facilitate acid demonstration for creators in my opinion, but zeny is SO easy to get, that I find it rather pointless to cater to laziness.

This is why I agree with 5%, as well as others do in this topic, stalkers have access to skills which require no kiels whatsoever to spam, they can default a reduction wing and hat all day long and spam like there's no tomorrow. Other classes do not have this luxury, and if they do, they certainly don't have crazy reductions to go along with them. THAT's the reason why stalkers don't need as much reduction as other classes, so 5% is fine. I think it should be buffed to +20% damage with bow-type weapons though, the damage isn't as great as you all believe it to be.

The robo eye issue has already been fixed, but I agree with the rest. Not so much on the Annihilation Event idea, as I don't see widespread participation either way, but the rest is good.

Bump, nerf the demi-human reduction it's over-powered, thanks. Give them more damage ya? :))

I absolutely disagree with adding a slot to it, or anything of the sort, spamming skills while defaulting a Forsaken Soldier on 23%+ minimal reflect seems like a lot to me. Adding '+ % hp' seems a bit too much to me as well, we're not trying to create super reflect paladins here, or make some sort of a super avian wing. It doesn't need a '+ stats' added to it either, I think it's effect being increase to 30% again seems like the best option. Being twice as effective as Avian, reflect wise, seems okay to me for what it is. 30% reflect is a lot and can be used very effectively by Lord Knights, Paladins, or any class for that matter against melee-type skill users.