I'm gonna vote for Appie!
Creativity : 4
I like how it's really themed around creativity with the render holding a giant pencil, but at the same time, it doesn't follow the rectangular shape most banners have.
Technical : 4
So it wasn't the most challenging piece, but the fading and subtle light work with the text and render was something most people wouldn't even notice. It's the attention to detail that takes the cake. I'm actually glad it's more simple, since it really is a banner, instead of an expression of a quote or saying.
Execution : 5
It's pretty much flawless. The color is great, the fade was great - everything. I mean...it looks very professional!
Aesthetics : 5
Such a pleasing color combination. I think the banner is the most utilitarian of the bunch - it appeals to the most people, and goes well with the theme. If it'll be used for future SOTW contests, I think most people would agree with that.