Reading through this topic, knowing it might be a little late, but either way, here's few of my favorites for past two years, which I think u might actually like.
Yumekui Merry ~ its probably the most sweet and amazing anime (beside Madoka) comming out in past months (or it's a year already? I don't really count..).
The Legend of the Legendary Heroes ~ if you like a little bit of historical stuff mixed with supernaturel, you will definitely love this anime (:
Dantalian no Shoka ~ this one is recent, and in my opinion as of now the only anime which caught my eye. If you have time, might aswell give it a try!
The World God Only Knows ~ oh, hi, if you like romance, this will perhaps be a good anime for you too. Though you might find it childish a little bit, it's really sweet. :D
Now however, for the old ones, I'd definitely go check out Munto. I loved it, though well you might find it a little old and confusing ;3