So you want people to instead of combining skills to kill people, to use skills until they hit their limit, then rely on melee to win? Relying on melee-only would of course make the victory only into a chance. A question of "Did I do enough when I was doing skills? Am I hitting enough with melee? How much longer can I last if I kill this person?"
LK's Aura Blade has no effect here. Are you kidding me with two hand quicken and frenzy? Are you saying that LKs will have to resort to frenzy in this PvP? Two handed = no shield = shit load of damage. Sure there's that 50% that you don't get hit, but what about the times that you do? It won't be hard to pop off 10k+ on you. Also, if they're fighting against somebody with sinx card, they can cloak and let your skill kill yourself.
WS, Creator, AND Clown all have low HP mods. Now you're suggesting them to get close to people that excel in melee combat? Clowns would constantly have to switch between guitar and bow if they want to AV AND melee at far range. If somebody gets too close when they have a bow on, they're done for since bow is two handed. Now, what can creator do with their homuns? They do very little damage and have very low HP.
Wouldn't matter in this PvP? So you're saying there wouldn't be class balance?
The priests that play rely on Coma. Now, what chance at coma would they have if they must continuously spam skills upon themselves? Kyrie Eleison/Assumption, heal, safety wall...
Stalkers get close to somebody? Stalkers have very low HP mods, and they have to rely on full strip to kill people most of the time. If they have BB copied, that implies getting close. So you want a stalker with maybe 200k HP get close to, oh I don't know, let's say a whitesmith, another class with low HP. Lets say the stalker does about 10k BB and has 2 FBH on. That's about 200 something SP with 2 FBH, and BB costs 22 SP. Stalker can pop off 9, maybe 10 bowling bashes. What's that, 200k total? Might kill the WS, sure. But lets say the WS also does about 20k cart terms and has RSX on. Now, cart term only costs 15 SP and is as easily spammable as BB. Whether the Stalker or WS wins, they will end up with considerably low HP, and won't be able to kill anything else.
A lot of servers I've tried whenever I get bored of Forsaken has berries being sold by NPCs.
Too stupid to make strategies? It is pretty difficult to have different strategies for every person, not to mention that you'd have to have multiple strategies for each person since they can change each time you battle, and not everybody does the same thing.