My opinions :
[ Zack ]
I like it but- it just isn't working for me. I love the idea of the render going over the border but this type of render doesn't work for that type of style. Why? Because if you look at the render, there's a light source going over its head. Once you notice it, you'll also notice that something's missing. Light. The effects are great but for me, it's just a little too simple. I think the text could be done better ( practice makes perfect! ) But overall, it's a really good signature / tag.
[ Zero ]
I'm not sure what's been done here. All I see is slapped on text, most likely the person used filters(?) to create this effect. The light source is coming from the bottom right angle, yet her whole face is bright. If something like that were to happen, there would have to be multiple light sources / focal points. So if I were to picture it in real life, the left side of her face would be darker than the right side. Overall, it doesn't really match the theme Disturbia for me, because all it does is look like you took a frame from the music video and just edited it some-what.
[ VapoRub ]
Just by looking at it, I find it that it's really unique. I just love how there's so much color- it just brings itself to life. It really brings out the theme Enchanted. The text at the bottom isn't too flashy- yet fits perfectly because of the dashes above it surrounding the square. Although it is simple, it matches the theme Music : Song & Artist very well. So great work. [:
[ Kittie ]
I love how it's so eye-catchy, the background left of Britney matches the text below it extremely well for me. Little dots at the background and the big dots for the text, it just- captures the essence of the theme. Like Icon said, you made Britney Spears look 10x better. Plus, the render & the background both blend well together, so no mistakes there. Overall, I love it.
[ xBlueberryx ]
If I were to first see this at the my very first sight- I would say it would be extremely colorful and vibrant. Blue, I really think you're getting a grip of your own ' style ' and expanding it on. The tag itself represents the song in a way- meaning like live your life bright- colorful- joyful. Like you said before, you could use a little work on the text. The effects are really great and flow well in the direction of the render too. So overall, great work Blue! Keep continuing on. (:
[ Tony ]
Personally, I wouldn't be voting for this. ( No offense or anything, this is just my opinion. So don't take this the wrong way. And sorry if I cause any drama ( this is just for future notice. ) ) Although I do love Ashley Tisdale, the tag just doesn't match her. Personally, I just find it as a massive barrage of brushes. Although the background would look great as a wallpaper or something, it just doesn't work with Ashley. Her render looks kind of pixelated in a way for me and it just isn't working out for me. She's not blending in very well+ there's a light source on the left side, yet she's placed on the right. That looks kind of odd for me. The text could also use a touch-up there too. Overall, for me, it just isn't capturing the theme of Headstrong.
Oh yeah and sorry if I may sound harsh to any of you, I just had to do this quickly before I went to school. .-.; So sorry again! D:
So my vote :
VapoRub.