I love number 2. It has captured the essence of the theme well and has added a touch of their own unique skills into the signature. You can see plenty of black representing mystery, conflict, death, and ultimately crime, and you also notice a well blended creepy hand that seems to be about to perform a horrific deed. Furthermore, the artist cleverly introduced the evil and dangerous ring from the Lord of the Rings into this crime-scene galore. This signature is a genuine masterpiece well focused on the topic at hand and has used their skills to subtly blend different pictures and elements into this spectacular art. There is not a doubt in my mind that number 2 should win this prize.